0 votes
14 views
ago in Computational Chemistry by (220 points)
How does the calculated dipole moment of a molecule using ab initio methods compare to the experimentally determined dipole moment?

1 Answer

0 votes
ago by (330 points)
The calculated dipole moment of a molecule using ab initio methods is an attempt to predict the dipole moment of a molecule based on quantum mechanical calculations. These calculations involve solving the Schrödinger equation for the molecule and determining the electron distribution and molecular geometry. The dipole moment is then calculated as the product of the charge separation and the distance between the charges.The experimentally determined dipole moment, on the other hand, is obtained through experimental techniques such as spectroscopy, dielectric measurements, or other methods that directly measure the dipole moment of a molecule in a given environment.In general, ab initio methods can provide reasonably accurate predictions of the dipole moments of molecules, especially when using high-level methods and large basis sets. However, there can be discrepancies between the calculated and experimental values due to several factors:1. Approximations in the ab initio methods: The Schrödinger equation can only be solved exactly for the simplest systems, like the hydrogen atom. For larger molecules, approximations are necessary, and these can introduce errors in the calculated dipole moment.2. Basis set limitations: The quality of the basis set used in the ab initio calculations can also affect the accuracy of the predicted dipole moment. Larger and more complete basis sets generally provide better results, but they also require more computational resources.3. Environmental effects: The experimental dipole moment is often measured in a specific environment, such as a solvent or a gas phase. The ab initio calculations, however, are usually performed for an isolated molecule in vacuum. The presence of a solvent or other molecules can affect the dipole moment through interactions like hydrogen bonding, polarization, or dispersion forces. To account for these effects, more advanced computational methods like the polarizable continuum model  PCM  or the conductor-like polarizable continuum model  CPCM  can be employed.4. Vibrational averaging: The experimentally determined dipole moment is an average over all possible molecular vibrations, whereas the ab initio calculations are typically performed for the equilibrium geometry of the molecule. To account for this discrepancy, vibrational averaging can be included in the calculations, although this can be computationally demanding.In summary, the calculated dipole moment using ab initio methods can be reasonably accurate and comparable to the experimentally determined dipole moment. However, discrepancies can arise due to various factors, such as approximations in the computational methods, basis set limitations, environmental effects, and vibrational averaging. To improve the agreement between the calculated and experimental values, more advanced computational methods and larger basis sets can be employed, along with accounting for environmental and vibrational effects.
Welcome to Sarvan Science Q&A, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of the community.
...